Our Story

The Itsa Pizza location has been home to many pizza restaurants over the years.  In 2016, Tyler and Katey Custer acquired the restaurant and, with the help of Sandy Dolan, brought back the town's beloved Sandos pizza recipes.  Since opening in May of 2016, Tyler and Katey have brought to the table their own personal stamp!  From grinding and seasoning their own sausage to new breadstick combinations and dessert options, Itsa Pizza is truly an old favorite with a new twist!

Tyler and Katey are both Arthur born and raised.  They both worked at Sandos under Sandy Dolan.  Actually, that is where they met!  They have been together ever since and have continued their lives in Arthur raising their own family.  They are happy to have the opportunity to serve and share their love of pizza with their community.  

Be sure to stop in to visit!